The ending of Naguib Mahfouz’s novel, Palace Walk, shows one of the main characters opening himself up to the reader. Like an oyster, he opened his strong shell to expose his soft inside. Throughout the entire novel, al-Sayyid Ahmad plays the tough dictatorial father who allows no questioning of his authority, and does whatever he pleases whenever he pleases. But in a dramatic change of events, Ahmad reveals that he isn’t only the strict tyrant that he is perceived to be, he is a delicate, innocent person who, like most other on this world, is torn apart after finding out terrible news about one of his children.
“The young man said with obvious sorrow, 'We are sad to inform you of the death of our brother freedom fighter Fahmy Ahmad… (495)'” Ahmad learns that his son Fahmy just died during a peace rally. He asks the soldiers many questions and among them is a comment which shows Ahmad's ignorance. Ahmad thinks that this was Fahmy's first rally against the war, well it wasn't. Fahmy had gone behind his father's back and attended other rallies before. He must have thought of the saying, “What daddy don't know, wont hurt him.” Well that didn't, but Fahmy's death did. And with Fahmy also died the tyrannical Ahmad that Mahfouz portrayed throughout the novel. Like Daniela mentioned in her blog, Hiding Behind the Wall, “...[H]e was too sensitive, he acted so rough with them to protect himself from being hurt by them.” She is talking about how he acts with his daughters, and this also applies to his sons. But after Fahmy died, he can't be tough on him anymore, and there is no more act.
Like previously mentioned, Ahmad wasn't the nicest guy in the world. He wasn't faithful either to his wife or his religion, he was mean spirited, and he obviously wasn't a good role model, but an even like the death of your child, that can really turn a person around. I'll sidetrack to my personal life briefly. Whenever my mother hears a story about how someone's son died, she says, “Ay no! Yo no podria vivir sabiendo que se me murio un hijo.” With that, she summarizes some of the feelings that Ahmad is having. He could not live knowing that one of his children died. No one can truly feel what Ahmad feels unless they are a parent themselves.
And Ahmad learned a lesson that any other parent in this situation would learn. As I believe Johnathan tries to get at in his blog Father's and Children's Relationships, he learns what the role of being a father is. The death of Fahmy is going to bring him closer to his remaining children.
Fahmy is now dead, but he left an inheritance of lessons for his family, and the first one to get his share, Ahmad, learned quickly, and changed his ways.
Works Cited
Mahfouz, Naguib. Palace Walk (Cairo Trilogy). New York: Anchor, 1990.
Showing posts with label Father's role. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Father's role. Show all posts
Thursday, April 1, 2010
Sensitive Soul-dier
Labels:
Ahmad,
Ahmad's break down,
Children,
Daniela,
Fahmy,
Father's role,
JNV,
Mauricio
Tuesday, March 23, 2010
Father's and Children's Relationship
Throughout the novel, we witness a lot of lying. The children and the mother, Amina, lie in order to be happy. Why do they lie? They are suppose to fear their father, since he is so strict. You would figure they'll obey Ahmad at any cost to refrain from getting any punishment. But, this is not the case. Toward the end of this novel, the narrator states:
Lying was not considered contemptible or shameful in this household. Living in their father's shadow, none of them would have been able to enjoy any peace without the protection of a lie. They openly admitted this to themselves....If they had been totally truthful with their father, life would have lost its savor (424).
The first sentence says lying is not look bad upon in the household, which is true because everybody in the house has lied in many cases. Ahmad disapproves with lying and catches a temper rage when he finds out somebody is lying, but then he turns around and lies. The next line says none of the children would have never made it without sneaking around Ahmad back. Lying is how they found happiness. Even Kamal lies and goes of after school without any protection his father demanded him to have. Further along this paragraph, it says, “If they had been totally truthful with their father, life would have lost its savor” (424). This is true in many cases, even for us. If the children would have told the truth every time and asked for permission before they do something, this book would be boring. By having the children lie it keeps us into to the book always wondering what if. What if Ahmad finds out? Lying plays a big role throughout the book, but why do they continue to lie and disobey their father?
When reading this novel, I made conclusions that all the people that live with Ahmad feared him. I suggested that fear overcame the love throughout their relationship with their father or husband. It is not that they feared their father, it is simply that they loved and respected their father. A father's role throughout the muslim culture is to support the family and to guide their children on the right path. In the muslim culture, it is different than what we live by. The parent arranges the marriage, based on what they think is best for the children. If the child ends up to be a failure in life, many people would blame the parents for what the child has turned out to be. It is not the Ahmad dislikes his children and wants to make their lives a living heal, it is simply that cares and wants the best for his children.
In one of Danielas' blogs, Hiding Behind The Wall, she talks about the sensitive side of Ahmad. She says, “The anger, strictness, and sternness with the family is simply a shield to prevent the family from seeing his sensitivity”(2010, Barajas). I agree with this a lot. Knowing the responsibilities of a man, he knows he has to set an example for his children; therefore, he has to be mean and strict to show his children how to become a man. We see a perfect example of this with his son, Fahmy. After Fahmy has disobeyed his father, he return asking for his father's forgiveness and approval on page 486. In response, Ahmad is thinking to himself, “My heart wishes to forgive him, but I'm afraid he'll think then that it's okay to disobey me” (486). Ahmad wants to forgive his son so bad, but he doesn't want to come off as being weak. Therefore, Ahmad is left putting on a slight attitude hinting to his son that he does forgive him, but that he is still mad an upset on what he has done.
In one of Yesinias' blogs, Hard To Understand, also taking about Ahmad passion toward his daughter's she mention the role of a father. She mentions in her blog, a father is the first man in a daughter life. This is very important, because the father chooses who she is going to marry; therefore, it is up to the father to shape his daughter according to what he thinks makes a perfect wife. All the times he has denied marriage offers for his daughter Aisha, was not that he was trying to mean and wanted to make her life miserable. He just wanted the best for his daughter. When Aisha is having the baby, Ahmad reacts and is worried about his daughter's life. He reacts saying, ““What's happened to my little girl? The doctor! Why is the old lady keeping me from seeing her?” (474). Here we see that Ahmad really does care for his daughter and that he loves her with all his heart.
The children lied because they didn't want to degrade their father. They understood that being a father means being strict and mean toward them. They understood that Ahmad only wanted the best for them. All the screaming and fighting was just tough love. So, they lied giving Ahmad the satisfaction of being a father, Ahmad wanted to be. Through all the toughness of their relationship with their father, they manage to see past that and find the love.
Throughout the whole book, I never really understood why Ahmad was so harsh with his children. I figured he didn't care about his children. After I read the whole book, I realized he was just being father. He was just looking out for them, and want to make sure as they grow up they'll be prepared for life. Ahmad says towards the end of the book, “It's true that fear makes men do foolish things” (476). All along he was just scared his children will end up hurt some way or another, so his only solution was to be strict and try to control everything they do to protect them.
Mahfouz, Naguib. Palace Walk (Cairo Trilogy). New York: Anchor, 1990. Print.
Lying was not considered contemptible or shameful in this household. Living in their father's shadow, none of them would have been able to enjoy any peace without the protection of a lie. They openly admitted this to themselves....If they had been totally truthful with their father, life would have lost its savor (424).
The first sentence says lying is not look bad upon in the household, which is true because everybody in the house has lied in many cases. Ahmad disapproves with lying and catches a temper rage when he finds out somebody is lying, but then he turns around and lies. The next line says none of the children would have never made it without sneaking around Ahmad back. Lying is how they found happiness. Even Kamal lies and goes of after school without any protection his father demanded him to have. Further along this paragraph, it says, “If they had been totally truthful with their father, life would have lost its savor” (424). This is true in many cases, even for us. If the children would have told the truth every time and asked for permission before they do something, this book would be boring. By having the children lie it keeps us into to the book always wondering what if. What if Ahmad finds out? Lying plays a big role throughout the book, but why do they continue to lie and disobey their father?
When reading this novel, I made conclusions that all the people that live with Ahmad feared him. I suggested that fear overcame the love throughout their relationship with their father or husband. It is not that they feared their father, it is simply that they loved and respected their father. A father's role throughout the muslim culture is to support the family and to guide their children on the right path. In the muslim culture, it is different than what we live by. The parent arranges the marriage, based on what they think is best for the children. If the child ends up to be a failure in life, many people would blame the parents for what the child has turned out to be. It is not the Ahmad dislikes his children and wants to make their lives a living heal, it is simply that cares and wants the best for his children.
In one of Danielas' blogs, Hiding Behind The Wall, she talks about the sensitive side of Ahmad. She says, “The anger, strictness, and sternness with the family is simply a shield to prevent the family from seeing his sensitivity”(2010, Barajas). I agree with this a lot. Knowing the responsibilities of a man, he knows he has to set an example for his children; therefore, he has to be mean and strict to show his children how to become a man. We see a perfect example of this with his son, Fahmy. After Fahmy has disobeyed his father, he return asking for his father's forgiveness and approval on page 486. In response, Ahmad is thinking to himself, “My heart wishes to forgive him, but I'm afraid he'll think then that it's okay to disobey me” (486). Ahmad wants to forgive his son so bad, but he doesn't want to come off as being weak. Therefore, Ahmad is left putting on a slight attitude hinting to his son that he does forgive him, but that he is still mad an upset on what he has done.
In one of Yesinias' blogs, Hard To Understand, also taking about Ahmad passion toward his daughter's she mention the role of a father. She mentions in her blog, a father is the first man in a daughter life. This is very important, because the father chooses who she is going to marry; therefore, it is up to the father to shape his daughter according to what he thinks makes a perfect wife. All the times he has denied marriage offers for his daughter Aisha, was not that he was trying to mean and wanted to make her life miserable. He just wanted the best for his daughter. When Aisha is having the baby, Ahmad reacts and is worried about his daughter's life. He reacts saying, ““What's happened to my little girl? The doctor! Why is the old lady keeping me from seeing her?” (474). Here we see that Ahmad really does care for his daughter and that he loves her with all his heart.
The children lied because they didn't want to degrade their father. They understood that being a father means being strict and mean toward them. They understood that Ahmad only wanted the best for them. All the screaming and fighting was just tough love. So, they lied giving Ahmad the satisfaction of being a father, Ahmad wanted to be. Through all the toughness of their relationship with their father, they manage to see past that and find the love.
Throughout the whole book, I never really understood why Ahmad was so harsh with his children. I figured he didn't care about his children. After I read the whole book, I realized he was just being father. He was just looking out for them, and want to make sure as they grow up they'll be prepared for life. Ahmad says towards the end of the book, “It's true that fear makes men do foolish things” (476). All along he was just scared his children will end up hurt some way or another, so his only solution was to be strict and try to control everything they do to protect them.
Mahfouz, Naguib. Palace Walk (Cairo Trilogy). New York: Anchor, 1990. Print.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)